This blog post is going to be about “What’s in a name?”
As a frequent critic of the feminization of the US military since the 1980s, a critic of PC permeating the US military in the 1990s & early 2000s, and more recently of the US military going Woke, it might sound bizarre that I vehemently oppose renaming the Department of Defense to the Department of War.
I hate lying.
Trump’s #1 selling point of the “rebrand” of the Department of Defense to the Department of War is predicated on a lie about US military history. The US military did not “go Woke” when the name was changed from the Department of War to the Department of Defense.
In fact, the leaders who led America to victory in WWII are the very architects of our post-WWII military structure and the formation of our Department of Defense. They were NOT Woke, they were serious and brilliant national security and military thinkers, who wanted to make sure that America was never again unprepared for war.
America’s Department of War was not prepared for war when we entered WWI or WWII. This is an historical fact, that every CINC and Secretary of Defense should know and it’s the entire predicate for our Peace Through Strength national security transformation after WWII.
So, I ended up fighting mad, honestly, after I saw some Hegseth Pentagon videos on X and I watched President Trump’s announcement of the Department of War “rebrand.” Their explanations to sell the “rebrand” are based on lies about US military history and I don’t know if it’s because they’re clueless nincompoops or just thought this sounded slick and tough.
What Trump said in this announcement is convoluted and untrue. The truth is that prior to the post-WWII establishment of the Department of Defense, America was NOT prepared for war, even though we had a Department of War. America entered WWI unprepared and undersized. General John J Pershing, the commander of the American Expeditionary Force in WWI had to rapidly mobilize, build and train a US force and arm them. America demobilized after WWI and at the beginning of WWII, our Department of War was again unprepared for war.
WWII produced some of the finest US military leaders in our country’s history and one of them, often referred to as the “Architect of Victory, ” General George C. Marshall, who ran the war, was dedicated to assuring that America was never unprepared for war again. THAT is how the Department of Defense came into being. It was a commitment to America having a military trained and prepared for war, as the best way to secure the peace. This was the beginning of America’s commitment to a Peace Through Strength national security policy.
Along with that comprehensive national security strategy and framework for our military transformation was a strong alliance structure with peaceful nations committed to the same goals. The creation of NATO became an integral piece of our national security framework and is America’s most important military alliance. The US military has over 75 years of leading and training with our NATO allies. Yet, NATO is another constant target of Trump disparagement and MAGA media spin efforts for the US to abandon. That Trump would want to trash NATO or MAGA idiots would drum up for the US to abandon NATO is insane and it would leave our military much weaker and be an America Alone policy, This “leave NATO” MAGA idiocy comes at the very time our adversaries, China, Russia, Iran, and North Korea are forming a closer economic and military alliance.
We would become weaker abandoning our most important military alliance, while our adversaries are strengthening theirs. How does that make any sense?
Hegseth tried to spin that George Washington, the commander of our Continental Army, who won the American Revolution set up the Department of War and America won every war until we changed to the Department of Defense, peddling this idea that the DOD name change was going Woke. Washington did want an American military prepared for war, and in the report pictured at the top, General Marshall too invokes Washington’s message. THAT is why he proposed America, finally, fulfill Washington’s recommendations, which had never been acted upon.
Yes, America won previous wars, but we incurred an enormous human cost in lives lost, due to not being prepared to field a highly trained and well-armed force. And Marshall believed that having a strong military prepared for war was our best deterrent to future wars – that is the very predicate of Peace Through Strength.
The book above, I have mentioned on my blog before and it’s one of my prized possessions. I found it in my teens and it’s the first thing I ever read about military strategy. I was hooked. General Marshall is one of my military heroes and to have his national security legacy mangled and twisted, by Trump, a draft-evader, hit me all wrong. Yes, Trump is a draft-evader – that is the truth.
MAGA world, which includes millions of vets and servicemembers, will blindly cheer on this sounding tough name change and they’ve bought into all of Trump’s MAGA spin, but the truth matters. Trump evaded the draft, knows nothing about military service or military strategy, and he twists military history, just like he twists facts, to suit his purpose. He is exactly like Bill and Hillary Clinton in this regard.
Trump twisted some General Pershing history to sell committing war crimes back in 2016, when he floated murdering ISIS family members as his plan to scare ISIS fighters into surrendering. General Pershing was another American military leader I admire. Interestingly, Pershing was so impressed by Captain George C. Marshall, in WWI, that he pulled him to work at G-3 and after the war he selected Marshall to serve as an aide-de-camp for 5 years. When WWII came along Marshall then went on to lead America’s military to winning the war. So, Trump has two big strikes in my book – he trashed Pershing’s legacy and now he trashed Marshall’s legacy.
The Trump administration facade of eliminating the Deep State has Hegseth talking about eliminating top generals, but the truth is Hegseth is totally unqualified to be Secretary of Defense or Secretary or War. He is not the Secretary of War; he’s the Secretary of Spin War. He puts together flashy videos and does beefcake poses, but his “warrior ethos” is hollow and all he’s done is create chaos inside the DOD. Cutting experienced generals and replacing them with Trump cronies or more FOX News celebs or Trump loyalists is not any way to build a stronger US military. I posted this on X:
The final YUGE hypocrisy is that Trump has hyped DOGE, DOGE and more DOGE, yet this big Department of War “rebrand” will cost billions of dollars and do absolutely nothing to build a stronger US military – all it does is sound tough. This is like little boys playing at war, not a serious comprehensive national security reform effort.


